San Joaquin River DOTMDL -- Technical Working Group

Study: Fertilizers Harm Freshwater Lakes

Associated Press - June 13, 2005
By Ryan Foley

Study: Fertilizers Harm Freshwater Lakes 6/13/05
By Ryan J. Foley, Associated Press writer

Farmers' routine application of chemical fertilizers and manure to the land poses a far greater environmental problem to freshwater lakes than previously thought, potentially polluting the water for hundreds of years, according to research published Monday.

Phosphorus in those substances has built up in the soil and will slowly end up in many lakes, where the nutrients lead to plant and algae growth in the water. The environmental problem, known as eutrophication, can turn pristine lakes into smelly, weed-filled swamps with lots of dead fish.

In a paper published Monday in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, a University of Wisconsin-Madison expert blames the buildup largely on industrial agriculture's excessive use of fertilizer and manure since the 1940s.

The concentration could cause the eutrophication of lakes for centuries as the treated soil slowly washes into lakes and streams, writes Stephen Carpenter, a professor of zoology and a leading expert on freshwater lakes. The problem leads to fish kills and the growth of toxic algae that can make lakes unsuitable for swimming.

"A very small percentage of the phosphorus moves into the lake each year and that small amount is sufficient to cause a great deal of water pollution," Carpenter said.
Paul Zimmerman, executive director of governmental relations for the Wisconsin Farm Bureau Federation, said he hadn't seen the report, but he defended farmers, saying they've improved soil conservation over the last two decades to make sure more dirt remains in place. Dams have made lakes more stagnant, exacerbating pollution, he said.

"You can't blame all eutrophication on agriculture," Zimmerman said. "Each year we're getting better and better. The eutrophication of lakes didn't happen overnight and it's not going to be solved overnight either."

Carpenter and other experts previously believed reducing phosphorus that ends up in lakes would be enough to protect their water quality, but the new research said phosphorus must be removed from the soil altogether to have an impact.

The study concludes that major changes in soil management are needed to reverse the trend. It may add urgency to government efforts to stop phosphorus from fouling up lakes and streams.

A Wisconsin task force earlier this month was formed to investigate ways to limit manure runoff contamination, which usually starts when farmers apply manure to their frozen fields. Farmers say they do so because they have no place to store the manure.

In the largest such incident this year, nearly a half-million gallons of liquid manure washed off a farm field in February into two streams that flow into Lake Mendota, dumping up to a ton of phosphorus into the lake.

Carpenter studied Lake Mendota, an urban lake in the Madison area that is a popular recreation and fishing spot, as a model for all freshwater lakes in rich farming areas. He said the lake's water quality has declined in recent decades, which will continue if left unchecked.

Carpenter said machines called manure digesters should be used to convert it into a sludge that can be put in landfills or transferred to phosphorus-deficient areas. He also said buffer strips should be developed to protect waterways from runoff and new technologies found to remove phosphorus from soil.

"If we don't do something," Carpenter said, "the water quality will get considerably worse, the lake will smell bad, there will be algae blooms all summer long, and more and more of those blooms will be the toxic kind."

Zimmerman said few farmers can afford manure digesters, which can run about $1 million apiece. Most in Wisconsin are found only on farms with 1,000 or more cows.

"It's way too expensive," Zimmerman said.#

Home Background Studies Meetings Resources Contact Search